Affordable Housing Keeps Residential Real Estate Performance Stable: Knight Frank

Knight Frank India released the 11th edition of its flagship half-yearly report on Indian real estate which presents a comprehensive analysis of the performance of both the residential and office markets across eight cities for the period January to June 2019. The highlight of this most-recent edition of the report has been the growth in affordable housing which has kept residential sales afloat despite a recovering market. On the office side the market has seen tremendous growth to reach an all-time high. The coworking segment has appropriated 15% of the share of this growth in office transaction volumes. Here are the quick highlights of the report:

Residential Performance Grows

Overall, the residential market performed well thanks to a stronger and more transparent regulatory environment. According to the report, launch of new units in H1 2019 rose by 21% YoY to 107,143 units while sales grew by a steady 4% YoY to 133,317 units. 51% of launches during H1 2019 occurred in the ticket sizes under INR 5 mn (INR 50 lakhs) and 78% under INR 10 mn (INR 1 Cr) thanks to developers’ focus on the affordable housing sector and lower ticket size offerings.

Residential Real Estate performance
Residential Real Estate performance (Source: Knight Frank)

While NCR and Kolkata saw a drop in unit launches, Hyderabad and Bengaluru grew by 47% and 34%, respectively. Prices have continued to stagnate and remained below the CPI across most markets. The weighted average prices in Mumbai, Pune and Chennai falling by a further 3%, 4% and 3% YoY, respectively.

In Mumbai, residential growth was mostly seen in the suburbs. Thane saw the largest quantum of new launches by some of the biggest corporates. The Peripheral Central Suburbs witnessed the highest sales growth in MMR of 9% YoY during H1 2019. Overall sales of housing units in Mumbai grew marginally by just 4%. Two factors affected the sales negatively – ambiguity around GST and the elections. In fact due to the ambiguity surrounding GST, most developers opted for the earlier GST regime with 12% ITC for on-going projects.

Gulam Zia, Executive Director– Valuation & Advisory, Retail & Hospitality said, “The mood of residential realty in Mumbai continues to be sombre and withdrawn. With more skeletons tumbling out of NBFC cupboards the shadows on Indian housing industry are getting longer. Affordable housing segment has emerged as a silver lining in these dark clouds.”

Office Market Performance Hits All-time High

The Indian office space sector reached a decadal high volume in supply and transactions in H1 2019. Office supply increased by 31% year-on-year (YoY) to 2.2 mn sq m (23.9 mn sq ft) in the current analysis period, the highest level achieved in this decade. Demand from the IT/ITeS (35%) and coworking (15%) segments have contributed heavily to the phenomenal growth of this sector.

Bengaluru achieved a historic high in transactions as well as supply during H1 2019 with transactions hitting 8.3 mn sq. m. while supply increased by over 100% at 7.6 mn sq. m. in H1 2019. Average rental values across the eight cities grew by 10% YoY during H1 2019 with Bengaluru topping at 13.5% YoY.

All India Office Market Performance
All India Office Market Performance (Source: Knight Frank)

Shishir Baijal, Chairman and Managing Director said, “The spurt in demand for higher end roles in the Artificial Intelligence and data security domains have led to a welcome and significant 59% YoY increase in demand from the IT/ITeS sector during H1 2019. Co-working spaces continue to drive transaction volumes and influence occupier demand”

In Mumbai, the transaction activity in the Mumbai Metropolitan Region (MMR) office market was strong at 0.43 mn sq m (4.6 mn sq ft) in H1 2019 thus registering a growth of 61% YoY. The Peripheral business district (PBD), Suburban business district (SBD) Central and SBD West were the three business districts which added supply in H1 2019. The SBD Central market particularly has been gaining traction, witnessing 143% YoY growth in transactions in H1 2019. Central Mumbai witnessed the highest rental growth of 6% YoY during H1 2019, followed by BKC at 5% YoY and SBD Central at 5% YoY.

Infrastructure Boosts Real Estate

The India Real Estate report also focused on the role of infrastructure in lifting living standards and thus boosting real estate markets. A number of infrastructure projects across the country have spurred construction activity in various micro markets. Some of these are Metro rail projects in Pune, Mumbai, Delhi-NCR, Bengaluru and Chennai, new roads such as the Mumbai coastal road, NPR and SPR in Delhi-NCR, new airports in Mumbai, Ahmedabad, 100 smart cities, industrial corridors and the very first bullet train project. The report states that if the Indian economy needs to grow from a USD $5 trillion economy to USD $5 trillion by 2025, then the government needs to increase its spending on infrastructure.

Bengaluru Trumps Mumbai in Uptick of Residential Market

It may seem as if the lean period in Indian real estate market could be turning the corner. Based on Knight Frank’s ninth edition of its flagship half-yearly report on Indian Real Estate for the period January-June 2018 (H1), the residential real estate market seems to be making a comeback from the slowdown caused due to ‘testing triplets’ of demonetisation, RERA and GST.

Knight Frank, an independent property consultant which routinely releases its analysis of the real estate markets around the world and India released this report on July 25th, a day when the Maratha Kranti Morcha called for a state and city wide bandh to protest farmer deaths in the Marathwada region. Most retail establishment across Mumbai were shut for the day and roads were remarkably empty for a city that experiences traffic jams all day. Thankfully the bandh was called off by evening so that people could get home safely. However, the scenario sums up the developmental issues our country and leading cities face, in the backdrop of which the positive news of renewed growth in real estate and its ancillary sectors is a much needed balm.

According to Knight Frank report which analyses the 8 cities of Ahmedabad, Bengaluru, Chennai, Hyderabad, Kolkata, Mumbai, NCR and Pune, there was a 46% YoY increase in units launched during the H1 period, while the increase in units sold was at 3% YoY in the same period. This marks the highest level of launches and sales in the last 18 months since demonetisation was rolled out at 124,000 and 92,000 units respectively.

Mumbai saw a staggering 128% YoY rise in residential launches, accounting for 40% of the total launches across the 8 cities covered in the report. However, the sales grew just 1% casting a shadow on positive sentiments. By contrast, Bengaluru saw a modest but very positive 11% rise in launches and even better 22% increase in sales of residential units. Other markets such as Pune, NCR and Hyderabad also saw a boost in the percentage increase of launches.

Report of Indian residential market
Report of Indian residential market (Source: Knight Frank report)

The key contributor to Mumbai seeing launches to the tune of 35,974 units is the dumping ground reprieve in BMC region and the parallel launches of mega projects in the peripheral suburbs of the financial capital. Dr. Samantak Das, Chief Economist and National Director – Research at Knight Frank noted, “Most developers focused on reducing apartment sizes of their new launches. Accordingly, we have seen shrinkage of 12% in apartment sizes across MMR, with some premium markets witnessing reduction of as high as 31%.”

Some of the key takeaways of the report were:

  • Mumbai saw the most number of launches at 128% YoY while NCR and Pune witnessed more than 75% growth.
  • Most launches were in the lower ticket size range wherein Bengaluru and Mumbai witnessed significant supply of units priced under INR 50 lakh and 1 crore, respectively.
  • Average size of units in MMR shrink by 12% between 2013 and 2018.
  • Mumbai, Pune and Kolkata saw prices of residential units drop by 9%, 8% and 8% respectively. The effective price drop was 10-15% after factoring in developers’ sops such as waiver of GST and stamp duty, and no floor rise cost to customers.
  • Despite growth in launches, government reforms and reduction in prices, sales continue to stagnate across markets. Bengaluru’s positive growth however prevents a pan-India decline in sales.
  • The growth-resistant state of the sector until now has also resulted in a higher Project Life Cycle (PLC) as the Quarters-to-sell (QTS) inventory remains stagnant at around 11.2 or 3 years.

Despite the encouraging numbers across most markets, the analysts at Knight Frank remained circumspect of the future growth of the sector owing to the continuing uncertainty in the market, high inflation and rising interest rates as well as the upcoming general elections.

Shishir Baijal, Chairman and MD, Knight Frank India wrapped up, “It could perhaps still be a rocky way ahead for the real estate industry and we all continue to look ahead for the impetus that is required for the industry to revive.”